38,515 suggestions

Missy Pantone
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Anna Coleman (Freaky Friday)
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Lucas Scott
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Janis Ian
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

PJ (Bottoms)
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

A.C. Slater
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Xander Harris
as Amber Mariens in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

John Tucker
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Reggie Peters
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Luke Patterson (Julie and the Phantoms)
as Torrance Shipman in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Seth Cohen
as Torrance Shipman in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Chloe Sullivan
as Raimiverse Peter Parker in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Adam Groff
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

JJ Maybank
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Faith Lehane
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Alex Nuñez
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Kayla Mannes
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Daniel Desario
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Michael Kelso
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Shawn Hunter
as Kelly Bundy in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?