Suggestions by @krmickey97

Zolita

as Sarah in If I Stay

Halsey

as Liz in If I Stay

Kehlani

as Liz in If I Stay

Hayley Kiyoko

as Liz in If I Stay

Willow Smith

as Brooke Vega in If I Stay

Rihanna

as Brooke Vega in If I Stay

Demi Lovato

as Brooke Vega in If I Stay

Dua Lipa

as Brooke Vega in If I Stay

Olivia Munn

as Bryn Shraeder in If I Stay

Katie McGrath

as Bryn Shraeder in If I Stay

Emilia Clarke

as Bryn Shraeder in If I Stay

Phoebe Tonkin

as Bryn Shraeder in If I Stay

Ana de Armas

as Bryn Shraeder in If I Stay

India Eisley

as Vanessa LeGrande in If I Stay

Margaret Qualley

as Vanessa LeGrande in If I Stay

Alexandra Daddario

as Vanessa LeGrande in If I Stay

Shay Mitchell

as Vanessa LeGrande in If I Stay

Zendaya

as Vanessa LeGrande in If I Stay

Andy Samberg

as Aldous in If I Stay

Patton Oswalt

as Aldous in If I Stay