38,454 suggestions

Lily Esposito
as Ellie Nash in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Ken Miller
as Ellie Nash in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Sam Puckett
as Ellie Nash in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Elle Argent
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Hilly (Weird Science)
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Joel Goodsen
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Carmen Ferrara
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Carly Shay
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Karen Foster
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Libby Chessler
as Evan (Superbad) in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Simon Spier
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Louise Miller
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Jeanie Bueller
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Chris "Oz" Ostreicher
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Amanda Beckett (Can't Hardly Wait)
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Kelly Taylor
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Troy Bolton
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Samantha "Sam" Montgomery
as Aaron Samuels in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Cole Johnson
as Anita "Needy" Lesnicki in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?

Lydia Deetz
as Anita "Needy" Lesnicki in Who would you crossover ship these high school characters with?