Suggestions by @krmickey97
37,301 suggestions
Judah Lewis
as Jay McGuire in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Alex Pettyfer
as Jay McGuire in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Dylan Sprouse
as Jay McGuire in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Austin Abrams
as Jay McGuire in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Chad Michael Murray
as Jay McGuire in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Ryan Gosling
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Charlie Hunnam
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Will Poulter
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Rudy Pankow
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Danny Griffin
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
William Zabka
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Paul Walker
as Christopher in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Kerry Ingram
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Beatrice Vendramin
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Louisa Johnson
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
AnnaLynne McCord
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Mischa Barton
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Jennie Garth
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Jennette McCurdy
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Claire Danes
as Amy Sutton in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)