Suggestions by @krmickey97
37,208 suggestions
Joe Keery
as Paul Mathis in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Miles Teller
as Paul Mathis in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Xolo Maridueña
as Paul Mathis in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Dylan O'Brien
as Paul Mathis in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Steven R. McQueen
as Paul Mathis in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Brad Pitt
as Derek Sandler in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Lucas Till
as Derek Sandler in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Natalia Dyer
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Winona Ryder
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Mila Kunis
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Emma Mackey
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Debby Ryan
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Aubrey Plaza
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Daisy Ridley
as Nicole Banes in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Tanner Buchanan
as Joey Mason in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Harry Styles
as Joey Mason in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Paul Rudd
as Joey Mason in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Timothée Chalamet
as Joey Mason in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Bill Skarsgård
as Joey Mason in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)
Aja Naomi King
as Maria Slater in Sweet Valley High (1983-1998)