Suggestions by @krmickey97
37,197 suggestions
Bailee Madison
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Rowan Blanchard
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jessica Alba
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Emmy Rossum
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Jenna Ortega
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Mary Elizabeth Winstead
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Natalie Portman
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Tatyana Ali
as Mary Anne Spier in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Sabrina Carpenter
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Lizzy Greene
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Sara Paxton
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Kirsten Dunst
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Angourie Rice
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Elle Fanning
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Mckenna Grace
as Stacey McGill in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Peyton Elizabeth Lee
as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Nina Lu
as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Momona Tamada
as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Tiffany Espensen
as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)
Miyako
as Claudia Kishi in The Baby-Sitters’ Club (All Decades)