Suggestions by @josephlychwala

Josh Gad

as Seymour Krelborn in Little Shop of Horrors (remake)

+6-5Score: +1

Nathan Fillion

as Professor Plum in Clue

+2-4Score: -2

Zachary Levi

as Mr. Green in Clue

+3-1Score: +2

Kristen Wiig

as Mrs. White in Clue

+5-1Score: +4

Margot Robbie

as Saddie Adler in Red Dead Redemption 2

+3-1Score: +2

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Dutch Van Der Linde in Red Dead Redemption 2

+3-2Score: +1