Suggestions by @jesselee

Ken Carson

as Ken Carson in This is Why We Lied

Jessie (Toy Story)

as Buzz Lightyear and Jessie in This is Why We Lied

Buzz Lightyear and Jessie

as Buzz Lightyear and Jessie in This is Why We Lied

Slinky Dog

as Slinky Dog in This is Why We Lied

Barbie

as Barbie in This is Why We Lied

Woody

as Woody in This is Why We Lied

Buzz Lightyear

as Buzz Lightyear in This is Why We Lied

Sandy Cheeks

as Sandy Cheeks in This is Why We Lied

Sheldon J. Plankton

as Plankton in This is Why We Lied

Eugene Harold Krabs

as Mr. Krabs in This is Why We Lied

Sally (The Nightmare Before Christmas)

as Sally Finkelstein in This is Why We Lied

Jack Skellington

as Jack Skellington in This is Why We Lied

Mr. Freeze (Dr. Victor Fries)

as Mr. Freeze in This is Why We Lied

Stromboli

as Stromboli in This is Why We Lied

Princess Peach Toadstool

as Princess Peach in This is Why We Lied

Luigi (Nintendo Character)

as Luigi in This is Why We Lied

Mario (Nintendo Character)

as Super Mario in This is Why We Lied

Mailbox (Blue's Clues)

as Mailbox in This is Why We Lied

Mrs. Potato Head

as Mrs. Potato Head in This is Why We Lied

Mr. Potato Head (Toy Story)

as Mr. Potato Head in This is Why We Lied