Suggestions by @jesselee

Madame Leota

as Madame Leota in Shadow Police

Animal

as Animal in Shadow Police

Miss Piggy

as Miss Piggy in Shadow Police

Fozzie Bear

as Fozzie Bear in Shadow Police

Kermit the Frog

as Kermit the Frog in Shadow Police

Jesselee

as Jesselee in Shadow Police

Betty Lou

as Betty Lou in Shadow Police

Oscar the Grouch

as Oscar the Grouch in Shadow Police

Count von Count

as Count von Count in Shadow Police

Guy Smiley

as Guy Smiley in Shadow Police

Frazzle

as Frazzle in Shadow Police

Jesselee

as JesseLee in Shadow Police

Huxley

as Huxley in Shadow Police

Miss Finch

as Miss Finch in Shadow Police

Donald Grump

as Donald Grump in Shadow Police

Prairie Dawn

as Prairie Dawn in Shadow Police

Elmo (Sesame Street)

as Elmo in Shadow Police

Rosita

as Rosita in Shadow Police

Zoe (Sesame Street)

as Zoe in Shadow Police

Abby Cadabby

as Abby Cadabby in Shadow Police