Suggestions by @jellytoyproductions

Keith Wickham

as Puffing Billy in The Adventures of Thomas (2026)

Lacey Chabert

as Emily in The Adventures of Thomas (2026)

Michael Palin

as Toby in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Colin McFarlane

as Bulgy The Bus in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Tom Kenny

as Bertie The Bus in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Steven Kynman

as Bertie The Bus in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Steven Kynman

as Duck in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Rowan Atkinson

as Edward in Island of Sodor Railway 🛤 Series

Rowan Atkinson

as Edward (NOT William Hope) in Thomas & Friends voice headcanons

Britney Spears

as Guest narrator 1 in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

Steven Kynman

as Duck The Great Western Engine in Thomas & Friends:Thomas's Thanksgiving Day (2025)

Colm Feore

as Toby in Thomas & Friends:Thomas's Thanksgiving Day (2025)

Joe Mills

as Toad The Brakevan in Thomas & Friends:Thomas's Thanksgiving Day (2025)

Joe Miller

as Toad The Brakevan in Thomas & Friends:Thomas's Thanksgiving Day (2025)

Gary Oldman

as Actors in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

John Goodman

as Actors in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

Bryan Cranston

as Actors in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

Alfred Molina

as Actors in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

John Cleese

as Actors in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends

Anne Hathaway

as Actresses in Fancasting the Narrator on Thomas & Friends