Suggestions by @jeanpaulvalley
10,725 suggestions
Ray Park
as The Headless Horseman in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Mila Kunis
as Lilith (Voice) in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Ian McKellen
as Doctor Septimus Pretorius in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Derek Mears
as Polyphemus in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Timothy Dalton
as Leroy Jackson/Spring-Heel-Jack (voice) in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Cyril Raffaelli
as Leroy Jackson/Spring-Heel-Jack (physique) in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Glenn Close
as Baba Yaga in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Mark Hamill
as Krampus (Voice) in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Arnold Vosloo
as Imhotep in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Ron Perlman
as Sheriff Robert "Bob" Wilkins in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Millie Bobby Brown
as Emma Carrey-Jones in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Jacob Scipio
as Marquo Verazquez in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Clara Page in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Dylan Minnette
as Joseph "Joe" Barber in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Timothée Chalamet
as Lucius Charpentier in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Jensen Ackles
as William "Billie" Von Tassen in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Mikey Madison
as Jessica Rooney in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Keke Palmer
as Jamie Couture in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Robert Downey Jr.
as Hector Johnson Jr in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow
Lucy Hale
as Kimmy Jovanovic in Nightmare in Sleepy Hollow