Suggestions by @ jdfitzgerald

Sian Taylor

as Bridget hatt in Tickled pink

Patrick Warburton

as Gordon in Tickled pink

+2-1Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Henry in Tickled pink

Jim Carrey

as James in Tickled pink

Taron Egerton

as Thomas in Tickled pink

Cole Sprouse

as Percy in Tickled pink

Michael Caine

as Toby in Tickled pink

Lacey Chabert

as Emily in Tickled pink

Michael Keaton

as Spencer in Tickled pink

+1-0Score: +1

Tim Curry

as Diesel in Tickled pink

Mark Strong

as Sir Topham Hatt in Double Trouble

Matt Lucas

as Sir lowham hatt in Double Trouble

Patrick Warburton

as Gordon in Double Trouble

Ewan McGregor

as Edward in Double Trouble

Taron Egerton

as Thomas in Double Trouble

Blake Clark

as Terence in Thomas and Friends (If it was owned by Hasbro)

+2-3Score: -1

Dove Cameron

as Rosie in Thomas and Friends (If it was owned by Hasbro)

+5-2Score: +3

Matt Lucas

as Sir topham hatt in Dream on

Ron Cook

as The Duke of boxford in Dream on