Suggestions by @jdeav

Drake Bell

as Jeff in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Nat Faxon

as Principal Slenderman in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Andrea Libman

as Fluttershy/Pinkie Pie in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Ashleigh Ball

as Rainbow Dash/AppleJack in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Tara Strong

as Twilight Sparkle in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Cathy Weseluck

as Spike in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Tom Kenny

as Booger in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Gavin MacIver-Wright

as Max in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Taika Waititi

as Director in My little Pony: Equstria Girls, All Hell Breaks Loose

Tara Strong

as Twilight Sparkle in My Little Pony: The Cave Story

Elizabeth Debicki

as Circus Baby in FNaF: The Anime

Eric Bana

as Nightmare Fredbear in FNaF: The Anime

Bill Skarsgård

as Springtrap in FNaF: The Anime

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Marionette in FNaF: The Anime

Lupita Nyong'o

as JJ in FNaF: The Anime

Jeremy Maguire

as Balloon Boy in FNaF: The Anime

Ruby Rose

as Mangle in FNaF: The Anime

Emily Rios

as Toy Chica in FNaF: The Anime

Josh Gad

as Toy Bonnie in FNaF: The Anime

Dane DeHaan

as Toy Freddy in FNaF: The Anime