Suggestions by @jasleenfaydelarosa
4,403 suggestions
Taffy (Lisa Frankenstein)
as Claudia Kishi in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Pam Miller
as Shannon Kilbourne in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Winnie Carruthers
as Dawn Schafer in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Sadie Harper
as Abby Stevenson in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Makani Young
as Jessi Ramsey in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
C. Berman/Ziggy Berman
as Mallory Pike in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Lisa Swallows
as Stacey McGill in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Skye Rotter
as Mary Anne Spier in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Sienna Shaw
as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)
Kelly Hu
as Dyanne in The Idol (80s)
Millie Bobby Brown
as Emily Riley in The Rage: Tamara 2
Joline Kaminsky
as Natalie Wood in Characters '60s adult actors and actresses play
Winnie Carruthers
as Lee Remick in Characters '60s adult actors and actresses play
Blair Underwood
as Jasper Jones in Littlest Pet Shop (80s Live Action)
Martin Sheen
as Roger Baxter in Littlest Pet Shop (80s Live Action)
Kelly Hu
as Youngmee Song in Littlest Pet Shop (80s Live Action)
Lori (Lisa Frankenstein)
as Tippi Hedren in Characters '60s adult actors and actresses play
The Creature (Lisa Frankenstein)
as Jack Lemmon in Characters '60s adult actors and actresses play
Keanu Reeves
as Ethan Daley in Euphoria (1989)
Marlo Thomas
as Suze Howard in Euphoria (1989)