Suggestions by @jacobwilkowilkinson

Olivia Munn

as Star Sapphire in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Ben Stiller

as The Atom in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Brad Pitt

as Cluemaster in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as Devil Ray in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Pedro Pascal

as Cheetah (Sebastian Ballestreros) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Henry Golding

as Superman of China in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Jonathan Majors

as Superman (Val-Zod) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Michael B. Jordan

as Superman (Calvin Ellis) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Tobin Bell

as The Joker (Henry Adams) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Joaquin Phoenix

as The Joker (Arthur Fleck) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Willem Dafoe

as The Joker (Jack Napier) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Karen Gillan

as Poison Ivy in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Eminem

as Captain Cold in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Dwayne Johnson

as Black Adam in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

David Tennant

as The Riddler in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Ryan Gosling

as The Joker (Johnny Charisma) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Adam Sandler

as ? in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Jack Black

as Toyman in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Rami Malek

as The Scarecrow in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU

Terry Crews

as The Joker (Albert King) in Casting The Full Character Encyclopedias Of DC Comics For My DCU