Suggestions by @ jacobtolentino

Jon Favreau

as Director in Brother Bear (Live-Action Remake)

Dwayne Johnson

as Sitka in Brother Bear (Live-Action Remake)

Jason Momoa

as Kenai in Brother Bear (Live-Action Remake)

Booboo Stewart

as Denahi in Brother Bear

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Scrat in Thomas & Friends: Ice Age: The Meltdown

Dwayne Johnson

as Diego in Thomas & Friends: Ice Age: The Meltdown

+1-2Score: -1

Mark Ruffalo

as Manny in Thomas & Friends: Ice Age: The Meltdown

Lily James

as Brooke in Ice Age (Recasted)

+2-1Score: +1

Mila Kunis

as Jane in Tarzan

+2-2Score: 0

Jackson Robert Scott

as Young Tarzan in Tarzan: Two Worlds, One Family

Mila Kunis

as Jane Porter in Tarzan: Two Worlds, One Family

+3-1Score: +2

Dwayne Johnson

as Diego in Ice Age (Recast)

Amy Adams

as Ellie in Ice Age (Recast)

Mark Ruffalo

as Manny in Ice Age (Recast)

Mark Ruffalo

as Manny in Ice Age

Mark Ruffalo

as Manny in Ice Age live action

Dwayne Johnson

as Diego in Ice Age live action

+2-2Score: 0

Dwayne Johnson

as Diego in Ice Age: Collision Course

Kevin James

as Manny in Ice Age: Collision Course