Suggestions by @ifancast
16,842 suggestions
Jack Quaid
as Jack Quaid in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Florence Pugh
as Florence Pugh in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Danny Pudi
as Danny Pudi in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Jesse Plemons
as Jesse Plemons in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Aubrey Plaza
as Aubrey Plaza in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Chris Pine
as Chris Pine in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Joaquin Phoenix
as Joaquin Phoenix in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Evan Peters
as Evan Peters in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Guy Pearce
as Guy Pearce in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Simon Pegg
as Simon Pegg in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Robert Pattinson
as Robert Pattinson in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Sarah Paulson
as Sarah Paulson in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Himesh Patel
as Himesh Patel in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Dev Patel
as Dev Patel in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Pedro Pascal
as Pedro Pascal in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Leslie Odom Jr.
as Leslie Odom Jr. in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Bob Odenkirk
as Bob Odenkirk in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
B. J. Novak
as BJ Novak in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Edward Norton
as Edward Norton in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler
Kumail Nanjiani
as Kumail Nanjiani in Every Actor Who I Think Could Play The Riddler