Suggestions by @goatjoker
14,609 suggestions
Nicole Kidman
as Best Actress 2003 in Oscars Do-over
J.K. Simmons
as Best Supporting Actor 2015 in Oscars Do-over

Penélope Cruz
as Best Supporting Actress 2009 in Oscars Do-over

Nick Nolte
as Best Supporting Actor 2012 in Oscars Do-over
Kate Winslet
as Best Actress 2009 in Oscars Do-over

Charlize Theron
as Best Actress 2004 in Oscars Do-over
Denzel Washington
as Best Actor 2000 in Oscars Do-over

Colin Firth
as Best Actor 2011 in Oscars Do-over

Leonardo DiCaprio
as Best Actor 2016 in Oscars Do-over

Amy Adams
as Best Supporting Actress 2011 in Oscars Do-over

Sean Astin
as Best Supporting Actor 2004 in Oscars Do-over

Hayden Christensen
as Best Supporting Actor 2002 in Oscars Do-over

Tobey Maguire
as Best Actor 2010 in Oscars Do-over
Jamie Foxx
as Best Actor 2005 in Oscars Do-over
Daniel Day-Lewis
as Best Actor 2008 in Oscars Do-over

Matthew McConaughey
as Best Actor 2014 in Oscars Do-over
Jake Gyllenhaal
as Best Actor 2015 in Oscars Do-over
Octavia Spencer
as Best Supporting Actress 2012 in Oscars Do-over

Frances McDormand
as Best Actress 2018 in Oscars Do-over
Sam Rockwell
as Best Supporting Actor 2018 in Oscars Do-over