Suggestions by @gabriellee1

Michael Cudlitz

as Lex Luthor in Christopher Nolan's Batman vs Superman

Tyler Hoechlin

as Clark Kent/Superman in Christopher Nolan's Batman vs Superman

Leo Aiolia

as Captain America in Cartoon All-Stars in the Marvel Cinematic Universe

Willem Dafoe

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman vs Dracula: The Long Halloween

John DiMaggio

as Black Mask (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Jeff Bennett

as Ragdoll (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Joaquim de Almeida

as Bane (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Steve Harris (actor)

as Ethan Bennett (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Lex Lang

as Clayface (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Stephen Root

as The Penguin (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Ellen Greene

as Mrs. Manface (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

James Remar

as Two-Face (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Jason Marsden

as Phosphorus (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

James Remar

as Black Mask (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Ron Perlman

as Killer Croc (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Dan Castellaneta

as Ventriloquist and Scarface (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Clancy Brown

as Mr. Freeze (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

FAKE

as Babyface (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Piera Coppola

as Poison Ivy (Matsudaverse) in Two Batmen from Two Earths

Jennifer Hale

as Poison Ivy (The Brave and the Bold) in Two Batmen from Two Earths