Suggestions by @fredericarrowsmith
59,100 suggestions
Steve Carell
as Penguin in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Paul Giamatti
as Penguin in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Stephen Graham
as Penguin in Batman ; Saviour Knight
Paul Walter Hauser
as Penguin in Batman ; The Goodnight Season
Chris Messina
as Sal Maroni in Batman ; Saviour Knight
Max Casella
as Sal Maroni in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Vincent Piazza
as Sal Maroni in Batman ; The Goodnight Season
Matthew Fox
as Two Face in Batman ; The Goodnight Season
Dominic West
as Two Face in Batman ; The Goodnight Season
André Holland
as Two Face in Batman ; Forever Dark
Sterling K. Brown
as Two Face in Batman ; Forever Dark
Bobby Cannavale
as Sal Maroni in Batman ; Forever Dark
Justin Theroux
as Two Face in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Jeffrey Donovan
as Two Face in Batman ; Saviour Knight
Crispin Glover
as Joker in Batman ; Saviour Knight
Chazz Palminteri
as The Roman in Batman ; Saviour Knight
Jack Huston
as Sal Maroni in Batman ; The Goodnight Season
Michael Imperioli
as Sal Maroni in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Harvey Keitel
as The Roman in Gotham ; Bat's Domain
Al Pacino
as The Roman in Batman ; Forever Dark