Suggestions by @eyricelovely

Spencer (Disventure Camp)

as Likes Both Characters in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Sofia (Disventure Camp)

as Team Glinda in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Rosa Maria (Disventure Camp)

as Team Glinda in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Lake (Disventure Camp)

as Team Glinda in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Ginger Fitzgerald

as Team Elphaba in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Crimson (Total Drama)

as Team Elphaba in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Tristan (Disventure Camp)

as Team Elphaba in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Natalia (Disventure Camp)

as Team Glinda in Team Elphaba vs. Team Glinda

Natalia (Disventure Camp)

as Trans Women in Fictional Face Claims

Iris (Ruby Gloom)

as Cyclops in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Yuko (Mia and Me)

as Elf in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Mia Marconi

as Elf in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Galinda Upland

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Elphaba Thropp

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Selina (Winx Club)

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Stormy

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Darcy

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Icy (Trix)

as Witch / Wizard in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Mariposa

as Fairies in Fictional characters based on its folklore

Taylor (Barbie)

as Fairies in Fictional characters based on its folklore