Suggestions by @eyricelovely
40,067 suggestions
Shannon Kilbourne
as Olivia Wilde in Which characters should actors have played in the 2000's?
Rosanne Katon
as Kelley Summers in Beacon Street Girls (70s Live Action)
Deirdre Berthrong
as Sophie Morel in Beacon Street Girls (70s Live Action)
Olivia Wilde
as Shannon Kilbourne in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Amber Tamblyn
as Mary Anne Spier in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Mary Elizabeth Winstead
as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Chad Michael Murray
as Logan Bruno in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Hilary Duff
as Dawn Schafer in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Lindsay Lohan
as Mallory Pike in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Amanda Seyfried
as Stacey McGill in The Babysitters Club (2000's Live Action)
Paul Walker
as Alastair in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Christian Bale
as Hayden in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Charlotte Ayanna
as Mabel in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Brandy Norwood
as Sarika in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Olivia D'Abo
as Agatha Everhart in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Deborah Knox
as Amber Fairfax in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Cillian Murphy
as Skandar Smith in Skandar and the Unicorn Thief (90's Live Action)
Ashley (Disventure Camp)
as Kit Kittredge in American Girl if Fictional Characters made it
Betty White
as Karen Wheeler in Stranger Things (80s Adult Cast)
Marilu Henner
as Max Mayfield in Stranger Things (80s Adult Cast)