Suggestions by @eyricelovely
40,015 suggestions
Eleven (Jane Hopper)
as Logan Bruno in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Aiden (Disventure Camp)
as Abby Stevenson in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Mike Wheeler
as Mary Anne Spier in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Lucas Sinclair
as Jessi Ramsey in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Brad Carbunkle
as Mallory Pike in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Tommy Ross
as Dawn Schafer in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Tyler (Mermaid Magic)
as Stacey McGill in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Jake Long
as Claudia Kishi in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Ben Tennyson
as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (if fictional characters but genderswap made it)
Molly (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)
as Tami in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)
Miss Collins
as Coach Jean Stoller in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)
Sue Snell
as Carly Simmons in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)
Tracy Campbell
as Stacy in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)
Ryler (Freaky)
as Leah Kilbourne in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)
DeeDee Martin
as Karen Smith in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)
Angela Franklin
as Janis Ian in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)
Ken Smith
as Damian Leigh in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)
Tippi Hedren
as Shannon Kilbourne in The Babysitters Club (60s Adult Cast)
Shannon Kilbourne
as Tippi Hedren in Characters '60s adult actors and actresses play
Nichelle Nichols
as Jessi Ramsey in The Babysitters Club (60s Adult Cast)