Suggestions by @eclipsestarling

Materialists

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Wizards of Waverly Place

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Karate Kid: Legends

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Thunderbolts (2024)

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

West Side Story (2021)

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Tick, Tick...Boom!

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

In The Heights

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Gossip Girl

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Sex and the City

as Takes Place in New York City in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Cherri Bomb

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Husk (Hazbin Hotel)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Vaggie (Hazbin Hotel)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Charlie Morningstar

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Jacob Frye

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Minerva (The Walking Dead)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Violet (The Walking Dead)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Clementine (The Walking Dead)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Shane McCutcheon

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Catra

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores

Adora/She-Ra (Disambiguation)

as LGBTQ Characters in Media in Oddly Specific Mount Rushmores