Suggestions by @dovidsteinberg
7 suggestions
Sean Bean
as Morgan in The Dresden Files
+26-4Score: +22
Willem Dafoe
as John Silver in Treasure Planet
+6-10Score: -4
David Tennant
as Delbert Doppler in Treasure Planet
+17-7Score: +10
Josh Brolin
as John Silver in Treasure Planet
+4-10Score: -6
Idris Elba
as John Silver in Treasure Planet
+24-12Score: +12
Andrew Garfield
as Jim Hawkins in Treasure Planet
+4-16Score: -12
Liam Neeson
as Galactus in The Fantastic Four
+61-36Score: +25