Suggestions by @ darthsebastian

Tom Felton

as Amun in The Prince of Egypt (1998)

Joaquin Phoenix

as Young John Connor in The Terminator Duology (1984-1991)

Cillian Murphy

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy (2023-2027)

+2-1Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy (2023-2027)

+4-0Score: +4

Dafne Keen

as Elizabeth Swann in Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy (2023-2027)

Hugh Jackman

as Aaron in The Prince of Egypt (2008)

Christian Bale

as Ramesses in The Prince of Egypt (2008)

Heath Ledger

as Moses in The Prince of Egypt (2008)

Dylan O'Brien

as Aaron in The Prince of Egypt animated movie [2028]

Crystal Reed

as Voice of Tzipporah in The Prince of Egypt (2018)

Ben Barnes

as Voice of Moses in The Prince of Egypt (2018)

Brad Pitt

as Bowen in Dragonheart (2006)

Kurt Russell

as Kyle Reese in The Terminator Duology (1984-1991)

+5-0Score: +5

Jeremy Irons

as Richard the Lionheart in Kingdom of Heaven (1985)

Max von Sydow

as Tiberias in Kingdom of Heaven (1985)

Nicole Kidman

as Tzipporah in The Prince of Egypt (1998)

Bill Skarsgård

as Riley Biers in Almost Cast: The Twilight Saga