Suggestions by @crazycritter
649 suggestions
Krysten Ritter
as Manhunter in Manhunter: Attorney at Law (2022)
Hayden Panettiere
as Kara Danvers in Supergirl (2008)
John Mulaney
as Captain Carrot/Rodney Rabbit [Earth-26] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
John Mulaney
as Captain Carrot in Captain Carrot and his amazing zoo crew!
Hamish Linklater
as Batman/Bruce Wayne [Earth-43] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)
Hamish Linklater
as Captain Leatherwing [Earth-31] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Hamish Linklater
as Batman/Bruce Wayne [Earth-19] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)
Matthew McConaughey
as Two-Face/Harvey Dent [Earth-18] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Charles Parnell
as J'onn J'onzz [Earth-18] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Billy Zane
as Lex Luthor [Earth-30] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Golshifteh Farahani
as Captain Al Ghul [Earth-31] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Geraldine Viswanathan
as Doctor Multiverse/Maya Chamara [Earth-8] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Natalia Dyer
as Mary Marvel/Mary Bromfield [Earth-S] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Hayley Atwell
as Wonder Woman/Diana Of Themyscira [Earth-24] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Michael B. Jordan
as President Superman/Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Alexandra Daddario
as Zatanna Zatara [Earth-84] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Katheryn Winnick
as Aquawoman/Ariel Curry [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Melissa Benoist
as Supergirl/Kara Zor-El [Earth-14] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)
Katheryn Winnick
as Aquawoman/Ariel Curry [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)
Michael B. Jordan
as President Superman/Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)