Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Greta Larson

as Kirsten Larson in American Girl Sorting

Anders Larson

as Kirsten Larson in American Girl Sorting

Molly McIntire

as Fake American in Sort by Tropes

Brooklynn

as Kit Kittredge (1934) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Miriam Mendelsohn

as Nicki Hoffman (2000) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Phoebe Terese

as Nellie O'Malley (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Dorothy Ann Hudson

as Maryellen Larkin (1954) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Dulcy the Dragon

as Claudie Wells (1922) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Trip the Sungazer

as Claudie Wells (1922) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Belle the Tinkerer

as Claudie Wells (1922) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Cosmo the Seedrian

as Claudie Wells (1922) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Wave the Swallow

as Nellie O'Malley (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Chris Thorndyke

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Gold the Tenrec

as Addy Walker (1864) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Blaze the Cat

as Addy Walker (1864) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Merlina

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Bunnie Rabbot

as Cécile Rey (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Silver the Hedgehog

as Marie-Grace Gardner (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Amy Rose

as Marie-Grace Gardner (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Maria Robotnik

as Josefina Montoya (1824) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have