Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Glinda the Good Witch

as Elizabeth Cole (1774) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Blake Belladonna

as Addy Walker (1864) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Korra

as Nanea Mitchell (1941) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Léonie Bélanger-Leblanc

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Léonie Bélanger-Leblanc

as Marie-Grace Gardner (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Saila Qilavvaq

as Cécile Rey (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Jenna McAllister

as Caroline Abbott (1812) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Jenna McAllister

as Felicity Merriman (1774) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Alexi Neele

as Maryellen Larkin (1954) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Taryn Brady

as Nicki Fleming (2007) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Gretel Grant-Gomez

as Kavi Sharma (2023) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Emerson (WellieWishers)

as Kavi Sharma (2023) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Elphaba Thropp

as Kavi Sharma (2023) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Jay (Lacey Games)

as Julie Albright (1974) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Beth March

as Josefina Montoya (1824) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Brianne Kovac

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Primrose Everdeen

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Kira Bailey

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Penny (The Rescuers)

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Alice (Disney)

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have