Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Sarah (FNaF)

as Sonali Matthews (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Lila Monetti

as McKenna Brooks (2012) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Will Taylor

as Jess McConnell (2006) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Luz Noceda

as Chrissa Maxwell (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Anya Forger

as Emily Bennett (1944) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Marina (Pericles, Prince of Tyre)

as Gwen Thompson (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Christine Wilber

as Gwen Thompson (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Tabitha Bing

as Sonali Matthews (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Riley (Jilly Bing)

as Lanie Holland (2010) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Anne Shirley

as Kirsten Larson (1854) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Anne Shirley

as Nellie O'Malley (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Maria Robotnik

as Luciana Vega (2018) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Saila Qilavvaq

as Corinne Tan (2022) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Honey The Cat

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Mabel Pines

as Isabel Hoffman (2000) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Dipper Pines

as Nicki Hoffman (2000) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Isabelle Palmer

as Sewing in Fictional Characters Sorted by Hyperfixations, Obsessions and Interests

Marinette Dupain-Cheng (Ladybug)

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Christine Wilber

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Amy Rose

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have