Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Mott (FNaF)

as Corinne Tan (2022) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Rory (FNaF: FF)

as Kailey Hopkins (2003) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Payton Thompson

as Sonali Matthews (2009) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Shelly Girard

as Luciana Vega (2018) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Cindy Mackenzie

as Lanie Holland (2010) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Samantha (FNaF)

as Addy Walker (1864) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Kasey (FNaF)

as Gabriela McBride (2017) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Kasey (FNaF)

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Gabrielle (FNaF)

as Marisol Luna (2005) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Kasey (FNaF)

as Marisol Luna (2005) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Delilah (FNaF)

as Nellie O'Malley (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Margie (FNaF)

as Marie-Grace Gardner (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Oscar Avila

as Mia St. Clair (2008) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Oswald (FNaF)

as Courtney Moore (1986) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Hazel (FNaF)

as Gwynn Tan (2022) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Greg (FNaF)

as Lanie Holland (2010) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Kimberly Bergstrom

as Lanie Holland (2010) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Oswald (FNaF)

as Saige Copeland (2013) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Jessica (FNaF)

as Jess McConnell (2006) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Jessica (FNaF)

as Josefina Montoya (1824) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have