Suggestions by @chris83

Tina Blake (2013)

as Susan Cabot in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Margo (Modern Girls)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Candace Kelmeckis

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Tina Blake (2013)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Heather Holloway

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Heather Duke

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Lexi Howard

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Eleven (Jane Hopper)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Padgett Sawyer

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

PJ (Bottoms)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Leah Burke

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Gabby (Thanksgiving)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Julie James

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Laurie Strode

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Hannah Fairchild

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Taylor (Imaginary)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Sienna Shaw

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Heidi (13 Reasons Why)

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Bella Swan

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Nancy Wheeler

as Natalie Wood in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?