Suggestions by @caitlinfrost

Zira

as Evil Matriarch in Sort by Tropes

Rachel (Animorphs)

as Blood Knight in Sort by Tropes

Killer Frost (Caitlin Snow)

as The Atoner in Sort by Tropes

Father Jack Hackett

as The Alcoholic in Sort by Tropes

Lykoi cat

as Leslie Willis in If DC characters were animals

Cosette

as Happily Adopted in Sort by Tropes

Atrocitus

as Genocide Survivor in Sort by Tropes

Cinderpelt (Warrior Cats)

as Dream-Crushing Handicap in Sort by Tropes

Cinderpelt (Warrior Cats)

as Career-Ending Injury in Sort by Tropes

Brightheart (Warrior Cats)

as Covered with Scars in Sort by Tropes

Kyo Sohma

as Tsundere in Sort by Tropes

Salazar Slytherin

as Snakes Are Sinister in Sort by Tropes

Kyo Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Kagura Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Kureno Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Ritsu Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Hiro Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Isuzu Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Ayame Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes

Hatori Sohma

as Hereditary Curse in Sort by Tropes