Suggestions by @brianasalentine

Cameron Monaghan

as Neji Hyuga in Naruto

Ruby Rose

as Yumi Ishiyama in Code Lyoko

KJ Apa

as William Dunbar in Code Lyoko

Keanu Reeves

as Charles Norbert "Chaz" Finster in Rugrats All Grown Up

Gomez Addams

as Charles Norbert "Chaz" Finster in Rugrats All Grown Up

Ryan Myers

as Gaara in Naruto

Seth Gecko

as It in Horror Movie Villains vs Creepypasta

Bill Skarsgård

as Jim Morales in Code Lyoko

Aaron Stern

as Odd Della Robbia in Code Lyoko

Macaulay Culkin

as Drew Pickles in Rugrats All Grown Up

Robert Pattinson

as Stuart Louis "Stu" Pickles in Rugrats All Grown Up

Brandon Flynn

as Eyeless Jack in Horror Movie Villains vs Creepypasta

Bill Skarsgård

as Jeff The Killer in Horror Movie Villains vs Creepypasta

Cillian Murphy

as Freddy Krueger in Horror Movie Villains vs Creepypasta

Mads Mikkelsen

as Grandpa Lou Pickles in Rugrats All Grown Up

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Tommy Pickles in Rugrats All Grown Up

Rabah Nait Oufella

as Jeremy Belpois in Code Lyoko

Brandon Flynn

as Ulrich Stern in Code Lyoko

Liam Neeson

as All For One in DC and Marvel vs Anime

Kristen Stewart

as Himiko Toga in DC and Marvel vs Anime