Suggestions by @bosuthebluehedgehog

Beast Boy

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Starfire (Koriand'r)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Green Lantern (DC)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Robin (DC)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Harley Quinn (Dr. Harleen Quinzel)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Deadshot (Floyd Lawton)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Carnage (Cletus Kasady)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Mr. Game and Watch

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Captain Falcon

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Rayman

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Pac-Man (Character)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Luigi (Nintendo Character)

as [CLOSED] Next Character in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Dan Fogler

as Mario (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Anna Brisbin

as Mrs. Potts in My Name Stitch! (Season 2)

Ross Marquand

as Mario (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Seth Green

as Mario (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Seth MacFarlane

as Mario (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Rainn Wilson

as Mario (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Josh Hutcherson

as Mario (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario

Matt Wood

as Mario (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #2: Mario