Suggestions by @bennystrikesback

David Huddleston

as Pa Kent in Superman (2005)

Sofía Vergara

as The Engineer in Superman (2005)

Thomas Kretschmann

as Metamorpho in Superman (2005)

Alice Braga

as Hawkgirl in Superman (2005)

Jeff Bridges

as Green Lantern in Superman (2005)

Wesley Snipes

as Mister Terrific in Superman (2005)

Joaquin Phoenix

as Lex Luthor in Superman (2005)

Winona Ryder

as Lois Lane in Superman (2005)

Cheyenne Jackson

as Superman in Superman (2005)

Blythe Danner

as The Witch in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Elizabeth Olsen

as Sam Thomson in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Hayley Atwell

as Joan Clarke in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Elisabeth Shue

as Bobbi Grey in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Brett Gelman

as Dave Schultz in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Sam Rockwell

as Mike Shiner in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Mark Wahlberg

as Mason Evans, Sr. in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Martin Sheen

as Judge Joseph Palmer in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Diane Kruger

as Cheryl Strayed in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Charlize Theron

as Amy Elliott-Dunne in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition

Emily Blunt

as Jane Wilde Hawking in Recast the Oscars: 2014 Edition