Suggestions by @bendle29
3,156 suggestions
Vice President Keith David (Saints Row 4)
as Slender-Man in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Nathan Evans
as Ticci Toby in Creepypasta (Live Action Movie)
Tom Ellis
as Slender Man in Creepypasta (Live Action Movie)
Joe Keery
as Jeff the Killer (Jeffrey Woods) in Creepypasta (Live Action Movie)
Tom Holland
as Yoshi in The Super Mario Bros. Movie
Blake Roman
as Yoshi in The Super Mario Bros. Movie
Nathan Evans
as Ticci Toby in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Shawn Mendes
as Vladimir Phoenix in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Charlie Puth
as Vladimir Phoenix in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Alexander Stewart
as Vladimir Phoenix in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Alexander Rybak
as Vladimir Phoenix in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Martin Portlock
as Alastor in Hazbin Hotel (Live-Action)
Jason Statham
as Black Mask in DC’s Villainous Madness
Taika Waititi
as Clayface in DC’s Villainous Madness
Kellen Goff
as Hoodie in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Gerard Butler
as Zalgo in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Josh Brener
as Eyeless Jack in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Blake Roman
as Jeff The Killer in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Jane The Killer in Creepypasta (Anime TV-Show)
Xochitl Gomez
as Mom in The Cat In The Hat (2026)