Suggestions by @asmfardous

Justice Smith

as Miles Morales/SpiderMan in SpiderVerse

+2-2Score: 0

Mahershala Ali

as The Prowler in Spider-Man

+2-3Score: -1

Justice Smith

as Miles Morales in Spider-Man

+1-2Score: -1

Andrew Scott

as Harry Osborn in Spider-Man

+1-5Score: -4

Katherine Langford

as Mary-Jane Watson in Spider-Man

+2-3Score: -1

Justice Smith

as Miles Morales in The Spectacular Spider-Verse: The Other [Animated Movie]

+1-1Score: 0