Suggestions by @andreagonzalez

Bonnie Wright

as Artemis in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+16-22Score: -6

Timothée Chalamet

as Nico di Angelo in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+34-88Score: -54

Johnny Depp

as Hades in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+215-72Score: +143

Sebastian Stan

as Poseidon in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+31-43Score: -12

Scarlett Johansson

as Aphrodite in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+106-90Score: +16