Suggestions by @ananymouse

Macaulay Culkin

as Victor Zsasz in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Bill Skarsgård

as Victor Zsasz in Batman's Rogues Gallery

James McAvoy

as Victor Zsasz in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Ralph Fiennes

as Mr. Freeze in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Bill Skarsgård

as Mad Hatter in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Keanu Reeves

as Deadshot in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Keanu Reeves

as Deathstroke in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Jesse Eisenberg

as Riddler in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Hayden Christensen

as Red Hood in DC Universe Reboot

Ian McDiarmid

as Alfred in DC Universe Reboot

Logan Lerman

as Red Robin in DC Universe Reboot

Lance Reddick

as Martian Manhunter in DC Universe Reboot

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Penguin in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Anya Chalotra

as Catwoman in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Robert Englund

as Hugo Strange in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Danny Jacobs

as Victor Z'as in Batman, Arkham Asylum:

Tasia Valenza

as Pamela "ivy" Ashley/Poison Ivy in Batman, Arkham Asylum:

Fred Tatasciore

as Bane in Batman, Arkham Asylum:

Steve Blum

as Waylon Johnson/Killer croc in Batman, Arkham Asylum:

Tom Kane

as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman, Arkham Asylum: