Suggestions by @aleksimalkavaara

Lawson Deming

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Lisa Valentine Clark

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Joe Silver

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Erik Lobo

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

John Irving Bloom

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Vincent Price

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

José Mojica Marins

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Maila Nurmi

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Rod Serling

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Ralph Richardson

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

John Kassir

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Cassandra Peterson

as Best Horror Host in Best & Worst of Horror

Lynne Verrall

as Best Witch in Best & Worst of Horror

Florence Schauffler

as Best Witch in Best & Worst of Horror

Tom Woodruff Jr.

as Best Gill-Man in Best & Worst of Horror

Don Megowan

as Best Gill-Man in Best & Worst of Horror

Tom Hennesy

as Best Gill-Man in Best & Worst of Horror

Ricou Browning

as Best Gill-Man in Best & Worst of Horror

Ben Chapman

as Best Gill-Man in Best & Worst of Horror

Alicia Vela-Bailey

as Best Ghost in Best & Worst of Horror