Suggestions by @aleksimalkavaara

Jack Nicholson

as 1960 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Donald Curtis

as 1950 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Peter Finch

as 1950 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Lee Van Cleef

as 1950 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Donald Pleasence

as 1950 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Hans Conried

as 1950 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

George Zucco

as 1940 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Bela Lugosi

as 1940 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Vincent Price

as 1940 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Henry Hull

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Dwight Frye

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Colin Clive

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

John Carradine

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Fredric March

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Claude Rains

as 1930 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Werner Krauss

as 1920 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Max Schreck

as 1920 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Lon Chaney

as 1920 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Rudolf Lettinger

as 1910 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger

Charles Ogle

as 1910 in Actor from every decade who could have played Freddy Krueger