Suggestions by @alanstudios

Kim Cattrall

as Princess Toadstool in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Ashley Judd

as Princess Toadstool in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Alex Brightman

as Enzo Mario in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Frank Welker

as Yoshi in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Todd Barry

as Bob Hoskins in Actor Biopics

Andy Kindler

as Bob Hoskins in Actor Biopics

Phil Collins

as Bob Hoskins in Actor Biopics

Corey Feldman

as Bob Hoskins in Actor Biopics

Simon Helberg

as Toad in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Todd Barry

as Mario Mario in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Alan Silvestri

as Composer in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Andy Kindler

as Mario Mario in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Corey Feldman

as Mario Mario in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Phil Collins

as Mario Mario in Super Mario Bros: The Fungus War

Thomas F. Wilson

as Tryclyde in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Brad Garrett

as Tryclyde in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Maurice LaMarche

as Mouser in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

David Faustino

as Link in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Christina Applegate

as Zelda in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Zelda in The Super Mario Bros. Super Show (recast)