Suggestions by @AegonVIlTargaryen

David Tennant

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Gary Oldman

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Jim Carrey

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Joaquin Phoenix

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Jeremy Irons

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Willem Dafoe

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Sam Smith

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Robert Sheehan

as Mephisto in Mephisto

James McAvoy

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Mads Mikkelsen

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Bill Skarsgård

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Diego Luna

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Keith David

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Denzel Washington

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Neil Patrick Harris

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Johnny Depp

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Robert Englund

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Mephisto in Mephisto

Tom Ellis

as Mephisto in Mephisto