Suggestions by @adrianpintado

Murray Hamilton

as Hosea Mathews in Red Dead Redemption (1970's)

Hosea Matthews

as Murray Hamilton in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Murray Hamilton

as Hosea Matthews in Red Dead Redemption (1980's)

Captain Harrison

as Leslie Neilsen in Characters actors have played or will play

Captain Harrison

as Bernard Hill in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Chaplain John

as Don Ameche in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Belle Rosen

as Elsa Raven in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Abigail Marston

as Natalie Wood in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Chaplain John

as Murray Hamilton in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

John Wayne

as Murray Hamilton in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Murray Hamilton

as Chaplain John in The Poseidon Adventure (1982)

Chaplain John

as Denholm Elliott in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Chaplain John

as 1972 in Fictional Characters Categorized by Year

Purser (Poseidon Adventure)

as William Hootkins in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Andrew Milton

as Paul Gleason in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Captain Harrison

as Paul Gleason in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Manny Rosen

as Don Ameche in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

James Martin (Poseidon Adventure)

as Robin Williams in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Mike Rogo

as Oliver Reed in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Manny Rosen

as Tom Wilkinson in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See