Suggestions by @adjutolu

Lana Condor

as Elise Whisks in The Selection Series

+100-46Score: +54

Lucy Hale

as Kriss in The Selection Series

+19-56Score: -37

Eliza Taylor

as Marlee in The Selection Series

+6-43Score: -37

Megan Fox

as Celeste in The Selection Series

+22-57Score: -35

Kiernan Shipka

as Annabeth Chase in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+120-149Score: -29

Ashley Benson

as Annabeth Chase in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

+9-41Score: -32