Voice actors that would have been more fitting to play adult Spike
For those who saw the My Little Pony series finale, we can all agree on one thing: having Cathy Weseluck (the voice of Spike as a child) play Spike as an adult wasn't a very good decision. The problem with that casting choice is that she didn't sound fitting for the right reasons: 1. Spike was a grown adult, and by then his voice would change and sound deeper and more mature. 2. Cathy didn't really try to make her voice even sound masculine; she just used her voice for when Spike sounded like a child, which wouldn't fit him by the time he becomes an adult. 3. Having a woman voice a grown male character doesn't work when their voice is meant to become deeper and more masculine (usually, when it's done for comedic purposes, it's fine). So, for this story, put down suggestions of male voice actors you think would have been more fitting to play Spike's adult form in the My Little Pony Friendship is Magic series finale (before, at least, Martin Roach would voice Spike's adult self in My Little Pony Generation 5).
Story added by rorysainsbury on March 6, 2026
Add a new role:
What type of role is this?
Or import all roles at once
Add at least 2 roles with cast suggestions to unlock Cast Chemistry analysis.
A comprehensive document for tracking all facts, history, characters, and rules within this fictional universe.
Curate the perfect soundtrack for your story — add tracks from Spotify, YouTube, or Apple Music to set the mood for your cast.
Loading comments when this section is visible...
