The Hunters opens on Ares Island as Norman Ryder jolts awake in an attic. A teenage girl enters, asking how long he’s been conscious. She introduces herself as Mindy Maron, explaining she found him unconscious on the shore and disarmed him. Norman demands his weapons and directions back to Hermes Island. She offers a ride instead, warning him ferries are scarce because the Hunters have been extorting the docks. Norman insists that’s impossible, he created the Hunters. Mindy explains they now control Ares under Rick Arthur. Norman decides he needs to see Rick. With no cell service, shut down by the Hunters—they head out. At a Hunter toll, Norman kills a guard before alarms sound. A chase ends in a crash. They are captured. They are brought to the harbor to meet Rick, who knows exactly who Norman is. Rick brings Mindy out before shooting her, then releasing Norman. Norman drifts into a bar, where a woman named Emma approaches. She offers him a chance at revenge—introducing him to Ashton Knight and Red Carraway. With a hit planned for the docks, Norman agrees to help. At an outpost, Ashton dies, but Norman takes control, executing a Hunter, warning the others. At the docks, Norman confronts Rick, disarms him, and kills him. Holding Rick’s body, Norman declares himself the leader. The men kneel. The film ends with Norman on a fishing boat beside Emma, warning that power never comes without challengers. He sends a message to Ellie Smith with his coordinates: The Hunters are back.