Benjamin is the middle child of the tooth family in Apartment 32. His parents are Clint and Madison, and his siblings are Joel, who calls him Ben, and his baby sister. He is found in his and Joel's room, absorbed in playing with his army toys. The player can join in by using the Army Guy Figure found in the bedroom. Playing with Benjamin will give the player some candy, and potentially the Teeth Pendant and the video game Kill to Shoot if they respond correctly to the dialogue options. To do this, pay attention and be consistent with which figures are the good guys or the bad guys, and take the comms guy figure when Benjamin offers it. Joel's comments, if he is in the party, will provide hints. Attempting to take one of Benjamin's toys when trying to get his attention will cause him to attack.