Ben Bernstein is a good-natured, simple Jewish-American family man. He's not particularly religious but considers himself Jewish. However, while signing for a new life insurance, he finds out he was actually born to Muslim American parents with the name of Abdul Latif Farah. Shocked by this revelation, he now has to hide his Muslim Arab identity, since his teenage daughter is dating the son of a nationalistic Israeli Army officer, and also trying to reconcile with his elderly anti-Zionist Muslim father, who would be shocked to find out his son was raised Jewish.